ReviewReviewReview300Mar 11, '07 2:03 PM
for everyone
Category:Movies
Genre: Action & Adventure
I'm one of about a dozen people, apparently, who didn't particularly care for Sin City. 300 is another adaptation of a graphic novel by the same author, done in a very similar style.

The problems that plagued the first movie centered around dialogue; what works in a comic book sounds ridiculous on screen. It's possible, I guess, to ignore this and to just enjoy the movie as a comic book come to life. I couldn't quite make that jump during Sin City, but with 300 it's easier to do.

The character development is selective (aside from a handful of people, there is no effort at all at it, which works fine), but more effective than in the last movie. The movie itself centers around the famous battle at Thermopylae in 480 BC. The outcome of the battle is never in doubt for the viewer. There is much testosterone-soaked chest thumping about honor, and some speeches about freedom which seem oddly out of place in a society where boys are taken from their families at seven years old and subjected to some pretty brutal military training.

There's also an interesting subplot involving whether the king has authority to fight a war without the authorization of the council, with various nefarious plottings to undermine his efforts. Different people will find that this resonates with their opinions on a different war, well, differently, but as the movie follows the graphic novel very closely and the graphic novel predates the war we find ourselves embroiled in, it's hard to say whether that's intentional or not. Of course, if I was making a pro-war movie in Hollywood these days, I'd deny it too.

Overall, worth a watch, and even the price of admission at the theater. Not terribly accurate on weapons and tactics or anything else, but if you walk in expecting to watch a movie based on a comic book based on a movie based on historical events, then you will get exactly what you want.

Oh, and there's nudity. Hooray for nudity.


10 CommentsChronological   Reverse   Threaded
rangerlee wrote on Mar 11, '07
The very first contact the Spartans made with the persians with the Phalanx was right on, they held the line, stopped the push, then the second line began killing with their spears while they all pushed forward. After that it all went down hill as far as their tactics go.

But it was an EXCELLENT movie for guys, even better on the IMAX.
rangerlee wrote on Mar 11, '07
ReviewReviewReviewReview
frenchkittymeow wrote on Mar 12, '07
But it was an EXCELLENT movie for guys, even better on the IMAX.
Yeah my womanly prowess is just not feeling that this is the movie for me.
hopems wrote on Mar 12, '07
Does stuff blow up? Because that's all I care about! :-D
jvon wrote on Mar 12, '07
Actually, yeah, there are some explosions. Explosions AND boobs. So Lee is right -- this is a great guy movie.
penabuluan wrote on Mar 13, '07
YIKES!
Went to see mmh... Pathfinder last week and saw the preview for 300....
AWESOME!!!
WILL DEFINITELY GO AND SEE!
Jay, have you seen Curse of the Golden Flower, no explosions but definitely there are BOOBS...
rangerlee wrote on Mar 13, '07
Yeah my womanly prowess is just not feeling that this is the movie for me.
Actually one of the best lines in the movie, "Only Spartan women give birth to REAL men"

Said by the Spartan Queen, wife of Leonidis to the Persian emissary.
jvon wrote on Mar 13, '07
have you seen Curse of the Golden Flower, no explosions but definitely there are BOOBS
No, I haven't, but it comes out on DVD later this month and I will rent it. :)
penabuluan wrote on Mar 14, '07
When you had the DVD, pay attention closely to the queen and the maid named Chan...
jvon wrote on Mar 15, '07
New trailer:
Add a Comment
How would you rate this movie? (optional)
   

Platinum Account



 


 
Enjoy my site?

Give to Spirit of America
© 2008 Multiply, Inc.    About · Blog · Terms · Privacy · Corp Info · Contact Us · Help